WikiIslam:Blocking Policy: Difference between revisions
m (→Usernames) |
|||
| Line 19: | Line 19: | ||
===Examples of Incorrect Blocks=== | ===Examples of Incorrect Blocks=== | ||
* An editor expressed an opinion we don't agree with: Editors have diverse opinions and they should not be blocked for expressing an opinion unless it is something universally illegal or extreme. Even then, editors can still contribute to this site while having diverse opinions. The first priority is having someone contribute positively to our site's main article space while complying with guidelines. Everything else is secondary. | * An editor expressed an opinion we don't agree with: Editors have diverse opinions and they should not be blocked for expressing an opinion unless it is something universally illegal or extreme. Even then, editors can still contribute to this site while having diverse opinions. The first priority is having someone contribute positively to our site's main article space while complying with guidelines. Everything else is secondary. | ||
* Someone made a mistake/typo or accidental edit | * Someone made a mistake/typo or accidental edit (that is not intentional vandalism). They might return to make positive contributions. | ||
==External Links== | ==External Links== | ||
Revision as of 02:11, 27 April 2013
Block Durations
Edits that ignore guidelines or are intentional vandalism should be blocked for 1-3 months if its an IP address and infinite if its a username.
Usernames
Obviously offensive/malicious usernames can be blocked indefinitely. If they have already made a constructive edit, they should be asked for a new username so they can be renamed.
Responding to Blocked Users
Reverts for vandalism or ignoring guidelines should be done with no comment or a comment similar to "reverting/reverting vandalism". No other type of comment should be used in the revert.
It is useless to respond to vandalism-only/content violation accounts on their talk pages. IP addresses change frequently so they're unlikely to read any messages. It is not useful to respond to a registered username which has been infinitely blocked because they cannot respond. If any comments are left, they should only be about the edit that was reverted. No personal attacks of any kind should be used.
Summary
No one should be blocked except for the following situations:
- Obvious and intentional vandalism, or ignoring guidelines. Inappropriate usernames with no edits can be renamed or blocked.
- Spam
- Harassment/gross incivility
- Continuing to edit after they have been told not to edit (for example if it is clear that a user cannot understand our policies, has been asked to stop and still continues to edit).
Examples of Incorrect Blocks
- An editor expressed an opinion we don't agree with: Editors have diverse opinions and they should not be blocked for expressing an opinion unless it is something universally illegal or extreme. Even then, editors can still contribute to this site while having diverse opinions. The first priority is having someone contribute positively to our site's main article space while complying with guidelines. Everything else is secondary.
- Someone made a mistake/typo or accidental edit (that is not intentional vandalism). They might return to make positive contributions.