User talk:1234567: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 47: | Line 47: | ||
:In addition, my sections on "Why Muhammad married X" were designed to debunk some of the myths, i.e., none of his marriages had a charitable motivation, any political motivations were peripheral, all but one of his wives were beautiful, until 626 he basically had to marry anyone he could get. This could also be a separate article. It would counteract some of the propaganda about how his polygyny was "necessary". | :In addition, my sections on "Why Muhammad married X" were designed to debunk some of the myths, i.e., none of his marriages had a charitable motivation, any political motivations were peripheral, all but one of his wives were beautiful, until 626 he basically had to marry anyone he could get. This could also be a separate article. It would counteract some of the propaganda about how his polygyny was "necessary". | ||
:We could perhaps amalgamate this article with the "list of wives" article (on which I've done some work). Make the list the hub article, then link it to separate pages on each wife, plus a few short articles on "Concubinage," "Muhammad's Broken Engagements," "Tetragyny," etc. | :We could perhaps amalgamate this article with the "list of wives" article (on which I've done some work). Make the list the hub article, then link it to separate pages on each wife, plus a few short articles on "Concubinage," "Muhammad's Broken Engagements," "Tetragyny," etc. | ||
:You can use the pseudonym '''Petra MacDonald''' for the author. This is the English translation of '''Asma bint Marwan''' (with the elements reversed). | :You can use the pseudonym '''Petra MacDonald''' for the author. This is the English translation of '''Asma bint Marwan''' (with the elements reversed).[[User:1234567|1234567]] ([[User talk:1234567|talk]]) 15:25, 11 October 2012 (PDT) | ||
Revision as of 22:25, 11 October 2012
Sorry about the auto block, I removed it now. --Whale (talk) 23:29, 25 July 2012 (PDT)
- Thanks. I fully understand why you have to do it on a site like this. It was only my own work that I deleted!
Muhammad and his Wives
Hi 1234567! First off, thanks for creating the new article on Muhammad's wives! The level of detail you went into looks incredible.
That being said, I have added our "under construction" template to it because it's style currently doesn't adhere to the site's guidelines. Articles should be free from sensationalist, emotional, humorous or sarcastic commentary. See this article, for an idea of what we're aiming for.
It would be great if you could edit it to conform with these guidelines. As a rough example, I have edited the conclusion of the article below:
Before:
Occasionally they defied the veil. Ayesha even started a war against her old enemy Ali, causing ten thousand Muslims to kill each other in one day. This disaster simply confirmed to the Muslim men that when women did anything important, misery followed. So the men banished their women to behind the curtains and then carried on killing each other anyway. Whenever Ayesha recited the verse, “Women, remain in your houses,” she wept until her veil was soaked.
It is easy to laugh at Muhammad, the champion adulterer who lusted after women and took as many as he could. Attempts to demonstrate that his marriages were motivated by politics or charity, or that his wives were old and ugly, collapse quickly. Nor is there much evidence that he treated his wives fairly or kindly, or that they were happy women. Of course this damages Muhammad’s credibility as the world’s greatest Prophet who was supposed to perceive realities beyond the boundaries of his own culture and whose life was the perfect example for humankind.
But there is a serious lesson to draw from this tragic story. One fifth of the world’s population nevertheless believes that Muhammad was a Prophet and the perfect example to the human race. Muhammad’s example as a husband sets the example for Muslim husbands throughout history. Muhammad set a bad example. That is why Muslim women still suffer to this day.After:
Occasionally they defied expectations. Aisha started a war against Ali, causing ten thousand Muslims to kill each other in one day. This confirmed to the Muslim men that when women did anything important, misery followed. Whenever Aisha recited the verse, “Women, remain in your houses,” she wept until her veil was soaked.
Attempts by apologists to demonstrate that Muhammad's marriages were motivated by politics or charity, or that his wives were old and ugly, do not hold up to scrutiny. Nor is there much evidence that he treated his wives fairly or kindly, or that they were happy women.
One fifth of the world’s population nevertheless believes that Muhammad was a Prophet and the perfect example to the human race. Muhammad’s example as a husband has set the example for Muslim husbands throughout history.Again, thanks for such a great article. --Admin3 (talk) 22:50, 10 September 2012 (PDT)
- Okay, I can convert it from "story" to "history" mode. But I'm on a time-budget so it won't happen immediately.
- In fact I may be adding more information as I go. I have found several more interesting facts on Muslim sites. However, most of these do not cite sources, and it will take me a while to work out exactly how we know what we think we know.1234567 (talk) 17:01, 11 September 2012 (PDT)
Page splitting and pseudonym
Hi 1234567. Since the article is very large, I think once you're done, it's best to split it into several pages (a page for each wife etc.). You can see examples of this (we call them "in-depth studies") here and here. We would also need a pseudonym (or real name if you're comfortable with that) for attribution on the "front page" and navigational TOC. Do you have anything in mind? --Admin3 (talk) 05:27, 11 October 2012 (PDT)
- I think this is a great idea! Unfortunately I'm not really sure how to use the software, so someone else may have to take responsibility for that. That's the advantage of a wiki - no one person is the author.
- Several of the wives already have pages, so we should think how we are going to amalgamate these old articles with some of the new information.
- In addition, my sections on "Why Muhammad married X" were designed to debunk some of the myths, i.e., none of his marriages had a charitable motivation, any political motivations were peripheral, all but one of his wives were beautiful, until 626 he basically had to marry anyone he could get. This could also be a separate article. It would counteract some of the propaganda about how his polygyny was "necessary".
- We could perhaps amalgamate this article with the "list of wives" article (on which I've done some work). Make the list the hub article, then link it to separate pages on each wife, plus a few short articles on "Concubinage," "Muhammad's Broken Engagements," "Tetragyny," etc.
- You can use the pseudonym Petra MacDonald for the author. This is the English translation of Asma bint Marwan (with the elements reversed).1234567 (talk) 15:25, 11 October 2012 (PDT)