Page history

CPO675

→‎Rejected as Apostates: Added a modern British Shaykh quote saying Qur'anist are Kafir

CPO675

→‎Criticism of hadiths

CPO675

→‎Verses that have no meaning and/or make no sense: Added academic quote on further verse issues that are with understanding the Qur'an by itself with citation for more in the book.

Asmith

→‎Verses that have no meaning and/or make no sense

CPO675

→‎Verses that have no meaning and/or make no sense: Added another unexplained verse and concept that has no explanation in the Qur'an itself.

CPO675

→‎Verses that have no meaning and/or make no sense: Furthered issues with God being the speaker from reading solely the Qur'an alone.

CPO675

→‎Verses that have no meaning and/or make no sense: Added a similar issue with the last two prayer verses of solely relying on the Quran.

CPO675

→‎Verses that have no meaning and/or make no sense: Added another difficult verse for Qur'anists around the seven oft-repeated verses not having a meaning - and difficulty of prayer verses.

CPO675

→‎Criticism of hadiths: Have added a video on scholarly/academic criticisms of hadith from a historical POV, covered by recent PHD from Oxford Joshua Little, highlighting the main points in titles and linking the video, so users can explore them themselves.

CPO675

→‎Other verses: Added a section on Quran verses support for hadith from the The Sahabah / Companions of the prophet.

CPO675

→‎Other verses: Added in another verse supporting extra-Qur'anic material, and linked Nicolai Sinai paper supporting this interpretation

CPO675

→‎Other verses: Added some more Quran verses stating to obey 'God and his messenger'. As well as interesting additional point on the change of this idea throughout the Quran with it only appearing in later Medinian verses, and provided an academic quote for this.

CPO675

→‎Verses that have no meaning and/or make no sense: Added in another verse that has no meaning without extra-Quranic material, and linked a short YouTube video on it.

CPO675

→‎Verses that have no meaning and/or make no sense: Added another confusing set of verses

CPO675

→‎Verses that have no meaning and/or make no sense: I have added another verse that needs extra-qur'anic material to make sense.

CPO675

→‎Verses that have no meaning and/or make no sense

Asmith

→‎Sunni-Shia Split

CPO675

→‎Sunni-Shia Split: Added in a section on Abrogation being impossible without extra traditions

Asmith

→‎Versus that have no meaning and/or make no sense: versus->verses

CPO675

→‎Versus that have no meaning: Added one more verse to this section.

CPO675

→‎Sunni-Shia Split: Have added a section on issues with versus having no or unknown meaning without extra-Quranic material.

Asmith

→‎Problems with Quranism

Asmith

→‎Problems with Quranism

Asmith

→‎Problems with Quranism: editing language to be encyclopedic

Asmith

→‎Why it is not possible

Asmith

→‎Rejected as Apostates

Asmith

→‎Rejected as Apostates

CPO675

→‎Five Pillars of Islam: I have added in some more scholarly information and citations on this topic, and changed some of the more polemical language to be more balanced which I will continue to review. And I've added a small section on the Sunni-shia as nothing on electing religious leaders is in the Quran.

CPO675

→‎Five Pillars of Islam: Added in a (very) small section on issues with Quranism referencing characters that are introduced without explaining who they are, or in the case of Abu Lahab, what they did to be condemned etc, that require secondary literature to explain.

Lightyears

Rejected the last text change (by CPO675) and restored revision 137502 by Lightyears: It seems much to tenuous to apply the verse in that sense.

CPO675

→‎Criticism of hadiths: Added a sentence on the hadith existence seemingly contradicting the Qur'an itself.

Lightyears

no edit summary

CPO675

→‎Criticisms: I have turned the title of the previous upload 'Criticisms' to a new section 'Further Criticisms' to take it out of the 'Five Pillars' section of the page.

CPO675

→‎Why it is not possible: I have added a new section covering criticism of having the 'secondary' revelations needed to understand the Qur'an leading to problems in interpreting it. As well as a brief explanation of isnads which I felt was missing on this page, and their dubious value only being used after 700AD.

IbnPinker

no edit summary

IbnPinker

no edit summary

IbnPinker

→‎See Also

IbnPinker

→‎Conclusion

IbnPinker

no edit summary

IbnPinker

no edit summary

IbnPinker

no edit summary

Asmith

no edit summary

IbnPinker

no edit summary

IbnPinker

no edit summary

IbnPinker

no edit summary

IbnPinker

IbnPinker moved page Qur'an Only Islam - Why it is Not Possible to Quranism

IbnPinker

no edit summary

Tharpa

→‎Conclusion: I have restored the change (without the explanation) that Sahab erroneously reverted. The comparison in the article was invalid. The earlier comparison I had was accurate but, as we saw, potentially confusing.

Asmith

no edit summary

Asmith

no edit summary