Autochecked users, Bureaucrats, Editors, oversight, recentchangescleanup, Reviewers, rollback, Administrators
19,746
edits
WikiIslam:Blocking Policy: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
no edit summary
m (→Summary) |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
==Criteria for Blocking== | ==Criteria for Blocking== | ||
The purpose of blocking a user (temporarily or indefinitely) is to prevent them from negatively effecting the site. | The purpose of blocking a user (temporarily or indefinitely) is to prevent them from negatively effecting the site. Potential editors who may contribute to the site positively are a valuable resource and should be treated with care. | ||
Administrators are required to be fair while blocking users. Heavy-handed or unfair usage of the blocking function effects the community negatively and can result in the loss of potential editors. Such blocks will be promptly reversed, taken seriously and reviewed so blocking must be done with great care. If a block can be disputed, other administrators must be consulted before a user is blocked. | Administrators are required to be fair while blocking users. Heavy-handed or unfair usage of the blocking function effects the community negatively and can result in the loss of potential editors. Such blocks will be promptly reversed, taken seriously and reviewed so blocking must be done with great care. If a block can be disputed, other administrators must be consulted before a user is blocked. | ||
| Line 9: | Line 9: | ||
==Block Durations== | ==Block Durations== | ||
The usage of an indefinite block can only be done for spam or | The usage of an indefinite block can only be done for spam, vandalism or intentional textual corruption. All other uses of an indefinite block have to be consulted with other administrators, especially if a block can be disputed. | ||
{| class="wikitable" | {| class="wikitable" | ||
| Line 20: | Line 20: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Vandalism: large amounts of text removal, replacing content || As above || This kind of vandalism is obvious. A user who has made a mistake or an error cannot be treated as a vandal if the edit can be discussed with them. | | Vandalism: large amounts of text removal, replacing content || As above || This kind of vandalism is obvious. A user who has made a mistake or an error cannot be treated as a vandal if the edit can be discussed with them. | ||
|- | |||
| Edits where it is obvious that the purpose is to weaken the criticism of Islam (which is our main focus as stated in our [[FAQ]]) and where the editor is not expected to change their opinions after discussion || As above || The purpose of some new editors is only to attack this site and the criticism of Islam. This is easily apparent in their edit. Other new editors may be attempting to improve the site and are therefore potential editors but may mistakenly weaken the criticism of Islam in a certain edit. Sometimes the intent of an incorrect edit is not easily obvious. The edit should be reverted and the editor should be messaged according to [[WikiIslam:Talk Page Guidelines|talk page guidelines]] about their edit. | |||
|- | |- | ||
| Comments debating the content of an article || As above || These comments can be removed and the usernames can be blocked. Site visitors are asked to visit forums for debates about Islam. Although responding to comments on talk pages relating to debate is optional, talk pages are for article improvement and not for debate (see [[WikiIslam:Talk Page Guidelines|talk page guidelines]].) | | Comments debating the content of an article || As above || These comments can be removed and the usernames can be blocked. Site visitors are asked to visit forums for debates about Islam. Although responding to comments on talk pages relating to debate is optional, talk pages are for article improvement and not for debate (see [[WikiIslam:Talk Page Guidelines|talk page guidelines]].) | ||
| Line 36: | Line 38: | ||
Reverts for vandalism or ignoring guidelines should be done with no comment or a comment similar to "reverting/reverting vandalism". No other type of comment should be used in the revert. | Reverts for vandalism or ignoring guidelines should be done with no comment or a comment similar to "reverting/reverting vandalism". No other type of comment should be used in the revert. | ||
It is not useful to respond to vandalism-only/content violation accounts on their talk pages. IP addresses change frequently so they are unlikely to read any messages. It is not useful to respond to a registered username which has been infinitely blocked because they cannot respond. If any comments are left, they should only be about the edit that was reverted. | It is not useful to respond to vandalism-only/content violation accounts on their talk pages. IP addresses change frequently so they are unlikely to read any messages. It is not useful to respond to a registered username which has been infinitely blocked because they cannot respond. If any comments are left, they should only be about the edit that was reverted. In accordance with [[WikiIslam:Talk Page Guidelines|talk page guidelines]], no personal attacks of any kind should be used. | ||
==Examples of Incorrect Blocks== | ==Examples of Incorrect Blocks== | ||
| Line 42: | Line 44: | ||
* '''Opinions''': An editor expressed a disagreeable opinion: Editors have diverse opinions and they should not be blocked for expressing an opinion unless it is something universally illegal or extreme. The suggested course of action is to change the topic of discussion and focus on issues relating to article content. The first priority is having someone contribute positively to the site's main article space while complying with guidelines. Everything else, including their personal opinions on different issues is secondary. | * '''Opinions''': An editor expressed a disagreeable opinion: Editors have diverse opinions and they should not be blocked for expressing an opinion unless it is something universally illegal or extreme. The suggested course of action is to change the topic of discussion and focus on issues relating to article content. The first priority is having someone contribute positively to the site's main article space while complying with guidelines. Everything else, including their personal opinions on different issues is secondary. | ||
* '''Mistakes''': An editor made a mistake/typo or an accidental edit (that is not intentional vandalism). They might return to make positive contributions. | * '''Mistakes''': An editor made a mistake/typo or an accidental edit (that is not intentional vandalism). They might return to make positive contributions. | ||
* '''Incorrect edits''': An editor made an edit which is not obvious vandalism but is incorrect in some way due to their current perception or understanding of an issue. They should be engaged on the talk page and given an explanation about why their edit was incorrect. | * '''Incorrect edits''': An editor with the intent to improve the site made an edit which is not obvious vandalism but is incorrect in some way due to their current perception or understanding of an issue. They should be engaged on the talk page and given an explanation about why their edit was incorrect. | ||
* '''Slight/occasional incivility/aggression''': Slight incivility can be subjective and occasional incivility can be forgiven. Maintain a neutral dialogue and consult with other admins if aggression continues. | * '''Slight/occasional incivility/aggression''': Slight incivility can be subjective and occasional incivility can be forgiven. Maintain a neutral dialogue and consult with other admins if aggression continues. | ||
| Line 51: | Line 53: | ||
* Obvious and intentional vandalism, text removal, replacement and/or corruption. | * Obvious and intentional vandalism, text removal, replacement and/or corruption. | ||
* The intent of an edit is to attack the site and criticism of Islam and where the editor is not expected to change their point of view after discussion | |||
* Continuing to edit after they have been told not to edit (for example, if it is clear that a user cannot understand our [[WikiIslam:Policies_and_Guidelines|policies]], has been asked to stop yet continues to edit). | |||
* Inappropriate usernames with no edits (they can be renamed or blocked). | * Inappropriate usernames with no edits (they can be renamed or blocked). | ||
* Spam | * Spam | ||
For all other situations consult other administrators before blocking a user. | For all other situations consult other administrators before blocking a user. | ||