WikiIslam

Parallels Between the Qur'an and Late Antique Judeo-Christian Literature: Difference between revisions

Page Discussion

Parallels Between the Qur'an and Late Antique Judeo-Christian Literature (view source)

Revision as of 20:59, 12 November 2025

74 bytes added ,  12 November
Automated script replacing USC-MSA hadith numbering system for Bukhari, Muslim, and Abu Dawud
[checked revision][checked revision]
(Removed superfluous/weakly evidenced paras re 16:103 in the intro and merged repetitive ones in the last intro section. Removed Baby Moses section as none of the things mentioned are actually in Exodus Rabbah, which is any case a late source from 11th century which we have avoided using elsewhere (also deleted Questions to Moses for that reason).)
(Automated script replacing USC-MSA hadith numbering system for Bukhari, Muslim, and Abu Dawud)
Line 44: Line 44:
==Possible Channels and Circulation of Stories==
==Possible Channels and Circulation of Stories==
{{Main|Pre-Islamic Arab Religion in Islam}}
{{Main|Pre-Islamic Arab Religion in Islam}}
The Quran itself (especially Surah Imran) is concerned that some people of the book were trying to lead the believers astray. Many academic scholars have further noticed that the elliptical and homiletic way many of the stories are told in the Quran indicates that their basic outlines must have been in circulation already, [[Pre-Islamic Arab Religion in Islam#Islamic Prophet Narratives|common knowledge to its listeners]]. Some even suspect that the direct stories were already circulating in Arabic and in pre-Islamic Arabic poetry. There is also a hadith narrated from Abu Huraira that the Jews used to explain the Torah in Arabic to the Muslims ({{Bukhari|6|60|12}})
The Quran itself (especially Surah Imran) is concerned that some people of the book were trying to lead the believers astray. Many academic scholars have further noticed that the elliptical and homiletic way many of the stories are told in the Quran indicates that their basic outlines must have been in circulation already, [[Pre-Islamic Arab Religion in Islam#Islamic Prophet Narratives|common knowledge to its listeners]]. Some even suspect that the direct stories were already circulating in Arabic and in pre-Islamic Arabic poetry. There is also a hadith narrated from Abu Huraira that the Jews used to explain the Torah in Arabic to the Muslims ({{Bukhari|||4485|darussalam}})


===Syriac Christian missionary activity===
===Syriac Christian missionary activity===
Line 56: Line 56:
Attributing vectors of transmission to individuals is a somewhat speculative endeavour, though there is significant evidence from the sahih hadiths that Muhammad initially converted to Abrahamic monotheism under the influence of a Hanif known as Zaid bin 'Amr bin Nufail. Meir Jacob Kister wrote a short academic article about this tradition. He quotes Alfred Guillaume who called it "a tradition of outstanding importance" as "it is the only extant evidence of the influence of a monotheist on Muhammad by way of admonition". Kister then details several versions of the tradition through different chains of narration (including in Sahih al-Bukhari, shown below), each of which convey the same essential message that Muhammad was converted to Abrahamic monotheism by Zayd, with minor differences. Commentators were very uncomfortable with the idea that Muhammad may have at one time eaten meat sacrificed to idols of even made such an offering himself. Kister considers the version which is most explicit on that point to be the earliest layer.<ref>Kister, M. J. [http://www.jstor.org/stable/613003 ‘A Bag of Meat’: A Study of an Early ‘Ḥadīth.’] Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London, vol. 33, no. 2, 1970, pp. 267–75</ref>
Attributing vectors of transmission to individuals is a somewhat speculative endeavour, though there is significant evidence from the sahih hadiths that Muhammad initially converted to Abrahamic monotheism under the influence of a Hanif known as Zaid bin 'Amr bin Nufail. Meir Jacob Kister wrote a short academic article about this tradition. He quotes Alfred Guillaume who called it "a tradition of outstanding importance" as "it is the only extant evidence of the influence of a monotheist on Muhammad by way of admonition". Kister then details several versions of the tradition through different chains of narration (including in Sahih al-Bukhari, shown below), each of which convey the same essential message that Muhammad was converted to Abrahamic monotheism by Zayd, with minor differences. Commentators were very uncomfortable with the idea that Muhammad may have at one time eaten meat sacrificed to idols of even made such an offering himself. Kister considers the version which is most explicit on that point to be the earliest layer.<ref>Kister, M. J. [http://www.jstor.org/stable/613003 ‘A Bag of Meat’: A Study of an Early ‘Ḥadīth.’] Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London, vol. 33, no. 2, 1970, pp. 267–75</ref>


{{Quote|{{Bukhari|7|67|407}}|Narrated 'Abdullah: Allah's Apostle said that he met Zaid bin 'Amr Nufail at a place near Baldah and this had happened before Allah's Apostle received the Divine Inspiration. Allah's Apostle presented a dish of meat (that had been offered to him by the pagans) to Zaid bin 'Amr, but Zaid refused to eat of it and then said (to the pagans), "I do not eat of what you slaughter on your stonealtars (Ansabs) nor do I eat except that on which Allah's Name has been mentioned on slaughtering."}}  
{{Quote|{{Bukhari|||5499|darussalam}}|Narrated 'Abdullah: Allah's Apostle said that he met Zaid bin 'Amr Nufail at a place near Baldah and this had happened before Allah's Apostle received the Divine Inspiration. Allah's Apostle presented a dish of meat (that had been offered to him by the pagans) to Zaid bin 'Amr, but Zaid refused to eat of it and then said (to the pagans), "I do not eat of what you slaughter on your stonealtars (Ansabs) nor do I eat except that on which Allah's Name has been mentioned on slaughtering."}}  


{{Quote|{{Bukhari|||3826|darussalam}}|Narrated 'Abdullah bin 'Umar: The Prophet met Zaid bin 'Amr bin Nufail in the bottom of (the valley of) Baldah before any Divine Inspiration came to the Prophet. A meal was presented to the Prophet but he refused to eat from it. (Then it was presented to Zaid) who said, "I do not eat anything which you slaughter in the name of your stone idols. I eat none but those things on which Allah's Name has been mentioned at the time of slaughtering." Zaid bin 'Amr used to criticize the way Quraish used to slaughter their animals, and used to say, "Allah has created the sheep and He has sent the water for it from the sky, and He has grown the grass for it from the earth; yet you slaughter it in other than the Name of Allah. He used to say so, for he rejected that practice and considered it as something abominable.}}
{{Quote|{{Bukhari|||3826|darussalam}}|Narrated 'Abdullah bin 'Umar: The Prophet met Zaid bin 'Amr bin Nufail in the bottom of (the valley of) Baldah before any Divine Inspiration came to the Prophet. A meal was presented to the Prophet but he refused to eat from it. (Then it was presented to Zaid) who said, "I do not eat anything which you slaughter in the name of your stone idols. I eat none but those things on which Allah's Name has been mentioned at the time of slaughtering." Zaid bin 'Amr used to criticize the way Quraish used to slaughter their animals, and used to say, "Allah has created the sheep and He has sent the water for it from the sky, and He has grown the grass for it from the earth; yet you slaughter it in other than the Name of Allah. He used to say so, for he rejected that practice and considered it as something abominable.}}
Line 97: Line 97:
Then there is this sahih hadith recording an allegation that Muhammad learned from a Christian:  
Then there is this sahih hadith recording an allegation that Muhammad learned from a Christian:  


{{Quote| {{Bukhari|4|56|814}}| Narrated Anas: There was a Christian who embraced Islam and read Surat-al-Baqara and Al-Imran, and he used to write (the revelations) for the Prophet. Later on he returned to Christianity again and he used to say: "Muhammad knows nothing but what I have written for him." … }}
{{Quote| {{Bukhari|||3617|darussalam}}| Narrated Anas: There was a Christian who embraced Islam and read Surat-al-Baqara and Al-Imran, and he used to write (the revelations) for the Prophet. Later on he returned to Christianity again and he used to say: "Muhammad knows nothing but what I have written for him." … }}


This Christian who taught Muhammad is not named in the sahih hadiths. However, Ibn Warraq, citing Waqidi, names him as ibn Qumta: "Waqidi [d. 207 AH D/823 CE] who says that a Christian slave named Ibn Qumta was the amanuensis of the prophet, along with a certain ‘Abdallah b. Sa‘ad b. Abi Sarh, who reported that 'It was only a Christian slave who was teaching him [Mohammed]; I used to write to him and change whatever I wanted.'"<ref>Summary by Sharon Morad, Leeds - [http://debate.org.uk/topics/books/origins-koran.html The Origins of The Koran: Classic Essays on Islam's Holy Book, edited by Ibn Warraq (Prometheus Books: Amherst, New York. 1998)]</ref>
This Christian who taught Muhammad is not named in the sahih hadiths. However, Ibn Warraq, citing Waqidi, names him as ibn Qumta: "Waqidi [d. 207 AH D/823 CE] who says that a Christian slave named Ibn Qumta was the amanuensis of the prophet, along with a certain ‘Abdallah b. Sa‘ad b. Abi Sarh, who reported that 'It was only a Christian slave who was teaching him [Mohammed]; I used to write to him and change whatever I wanted.'"<ref>Summary by Sharon Morad, Leeds - [http://debate.org.uk/topics/books/origins-koran.html The Origins of The Koran: Classic Essays on Islam's Holy Book, edited by Ibn Warraq (Prometheus Books: Amherst, New York. 1998)]</ref>


Another hadith mentions a Christian called Waraqa b. Naufal b. Asad b. 'Abd al-'Uzza, who used to write the Christian scriptures in Arabic:
Another hadith mentions a Christian called Waraqa b. Naufal b. Asad b. 'Abd al-'Uzza, who used to write the Christian scriptures in Arabic:
{{Quote|{{Muslim|1|301}}|
{{Quote|{{Muslim||160a|reference}}|
Khadija then took him to Waraqa b. Naufal b. Asad b. 'Abd al-'Uzza, and he was the son of Khadija's uncle, i. e., the brother of her father. And he was the man who had embraced Christianity in the Days of Ignorance (i. e. before Islam) and he used to write books in Arabic and, therefore, wrote Injil in Arabic as God willed that he should write. He was very old and had become blind Khadija said to him: O uncle! listen to the son of your brother.}}
Khadija then took him to Waraqa b. Naufal b. Asad b. 'Abd al-'Uzza, and he was the son of Khadija's uncle, i. e., the brother of her father. And he was the man who had embraced Christianity in the Days of Ignorance (i. e. before Islam) and he used to write books in Arabic and, therefore, wrote Injil in Arabic as God willed that he should write. He was very old and had become blind Khadija said to him: O uncle! listen to the son of your brother.}}


Thus, beyond what seems to have been a general circulation of Judeo-Christian stories (and the Quran attesting the presence of and complaining about the people of the book), there are various individuals from whom Muhammad may have heard these tales, beginning with Zaid bin 'Amr bin Nufail and from Waraqa bin Naufal bin Asad bin 'Abdul 'Uzza, to Jabr and the un-named Christian of {{Bukhari|4|56|814}}.  
Thus, beyond what seems to have been a general circulation of Judeo-Christian stories (and the Quran attesting the presence of and complaining about the people of the book), there are various individuals from whom Muhammad may have heard these tales, beginning with Zaid bin 'Amr bin Nufail and from Waraqa bin Naufal bin Asad bin 'Abdul 'Uzza, to Jabr and the un-named Christian of {{Bukhari|||3617|darussalam}}.  


===Muslim Views===
===Muslim Views===
Line 125: Line 125:
{{Quote|{{citation|title=The Life of Muhammad|trans_title=Sirat Rasul Allah|ISBN=0-19-636033-1|year=1955|publisher=Oxford UP|author1=Ibn Ishaq (d. 768)|author2=Ibn Hisham (d. 833)|editor=A. Guillaume|url=https://archive.org/details/GuillaumeATheLifeOfMuhammad/page/n1/mode/2up|page=86}}|"Layth Abu Sulaym alleged that they found a stone in the Kaba forty years before the prophet's mission, if what they say is true, containing the inscription "He that soweth good shall reap joy; he that soweth evil shall reap sorrow; can you do evil and be rewarded with good? Nay, as grapes cannot be gathered from thorns"}}
{{Quote|{{citation|title=The Life of Muhammad|trans_title=Sirat Rasul Allah|ISBN=0-19-636033-1|year=1955|publisher=Oxford UP|author1=Ibn Ishaq (d. 768)|author2=Ibn Hisham (d. 833)|editor=A. Guillaume|url=https://archive.org/details/GuillaumeATheLifeOfMuhammad/page/n1/mode/2up|page=86}}|"Layth Abu Sulaym alleged that they found a stone in the Kaba forty years before the prophet's mission, if what they say is true, containing the inscription "He that soweth good shall reap joy; he that soweth evil shall reap sorrow; can you do evil and be rewarded with good? Nay, as grapes cannot be gathered from thorns"}}


There were also eye-witness reports that figures of Mary and Jesus were in the Kaaba narrated from Muslims who died in the early 2nd century.<ref>See this [https://twitter.com/shahanSean/status/1546629237053988867 Twitter thread] by Professor Sean Anthony - 11 July 2022 ([https://web.archive.org/web/20220712025357/https://twitter.com/shahanSean/status/1546629237053988867 archive])</ref> Even according to a hadith, the Ka’aba may have contained pictures of Abraham and Mary (similarly, see {{Bukhari|4|55|571}}):
There were also eye-witness reports that figures of Mary and Jesus were in the Kaaba narrated from Muslims who died in the early 2nd century.<ref>See this [https://twitter.com/shahanSean/status/1546629237053988867 Twitter thread] by Professor Sean Anthony - 11 July 2022 ([https://web.archive.org/web/20220712025357/https://twitter.com/shahanSean/status/1546629237053988867 archive])</ref> Even according to a hadith, the Ka’aba may have contained pictures of Abraham and Mary (similarly, see {{Bukhari|||3352|darussalam}}):


{{Quote|{{Bukhari|4|55|570}}|Narrated Ibn Abbas: The Prophet entered the Ka'ba and found in it the pictures of (Prophet) Abraham and Mary. On that he said' "What is the matter with them ( i.e. Quraish)? They have already heard that angels do not enter a house in which there are pictures; yet this is the picture of Abraham. And why is he depicted as practicing divination by arrows?"}}  
{{Quote|{{Bukhari|||3351|darussalam}}|Narrated Ibn Abbas: The Prophet entered the Ka'ba and found in it the pictures of (Prophet) Abraham and Mary. On that he said' "What is the matter with them ( i.e. Quraish)? They have already heard that angels do not enter a house in which there are pictures; yet this is the picture of Abraham. And why is he depicted as practicing divination by arrows?"}}  


It seem to be the case that, in actuality, there were Jews elsewhere outside of Yathrib and surrounding areas of Northern Hijaz. So far, there is limited evidence of a small number of Christians present in Mecca.<ref>See this [https://twitter.com/shahanSean/status/1546498794967154695 Twitter.com] thread involving Professor Sean Anthony - 11 July 2022</ref>
It seem to be the case that, in actuality, there were Jews elsewhere outside of Yathrib and surrounding areas of Northern Hijaz. So far, there is limited evidence of a small number of Christians present in Mecca.<ref>See this [https://twitter.com/shahanSean/status/1546498794967154695 Twitter.com] thread involving Professor Sean Anthony - 11 July 2022</ref>
Line 858: Line 858:
== Different Ranks of Believers in Paradise ==
== Different Ranks of Believers in Paradise ==
{{Quote|{{Quran|17|21}}|See, how We have exalted some above others in this world, and in the Life to Come they will have higher ranks and greater degrees of excellence over others.}}{{Quote|{{Quran|8|4}}|It is they who are truly the faithful. They shall have ranks near their Lord, forgiveness and a noble provision.}}{{Quote|{{Quran|46|19}}|Of these all have ranks according to their deeds so that Allah may fully recompense them for their deeds. They shall not be wronged.}}Just like people on earth are not equal, with many having different ranks ''<nowiki/>'darajāt'''<ref>''darajah'' - [https://lexicon.quranic-research.net/pdf/Page_0869.pdf Lanes Lexicon Classical Arabic Dictionary p.869]
{{Quote|{{Quran|17|21}}|See, how We have exalted some above others in this world, and in the Life to Come they will have higher ranks and greater degrees of excellence over others.}}{{Quote|{{Quran|8|4}}|It is they who are truly the faithful. They shall have ranks near their Lord, forgiveness and a noble provision.}}{{Quote|{{Quran|46|19}}|Of these all have ranks according to their deeds so that Allah may fully recompense them for their deeds. They shall not be wronged.}}Just like people on earth are not equal, with many having different ranks ''<nowiki/>'darajāt'''<ref>''darajah'' - [https://lexicon.quranic-research.net/pdf/Page_0869.pdf Lanes Lexicon Classical Arabic Dictionary p.869]
Lane's Lexicon Quranic Research - [https://lexicon.quranic-research.net/data/08_d/044_drj.html ''root درج'']</ref> (e.g. men are a rank above women {{Quran|2|228}}, some messengers are ranked higher than others {{Quran|2|253}}, and people generally {{Quran|6|165}}),<ref>See uses of the word for ranks/degrees applied to people in the Qur'an on the noun section of [https://corpus.quran.com/qurandictionary.jsp?q=drj Qur'an Corpus root ''dāl rā jīm'' (د ر ج) page]</ref> those in the afterlife among the believers similarly have different ranks/degrees.<ref>''darajah | rank'' Sinai, Nicolai. ''Key Terms of the Qur'an: A Critical Dictionary (p.283-289).'' Princeton University Press. Kindle Edition.</ref> Sinai (2023) notes verses such as {{Quran-range|8|2|4}}, {{Quran|20|75}}, {{Quran|4|95–96}}, {{Quran|9|20}} and {{Quran|58|11}} suggest that degrees of belief, action, and knowledge appear to lead to these differences in eschatological rewards''.''<ref>Ibid pp. 288.</ref> This idea is further confirmed in hadith, such as {{Bukhari|9|93|519}} and Qur'anic commentaries.<ref>E.g. commentaries on [https://quranx.com/tafsirs/46.19 Q46:19], [https://quranx.com/tafsirs/8.4 Q8:4], [https://quranx.com/Tafsirs/17.21 Q17:21] or any other verse listed in this section.</ref> No such concept of heavenly ranks exists in the New Testament. There is only the vague statement in [https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=matthew%2016:27&version=NIV Matthew 16:27] (and similar ones in the Pauline epistles and Revelation) that "The Son of Man ... will reward each person according to what they have done."
Lane's Lexicon Quranic Research - [https://lexicon.quranic-research.net/data/08_d/044_drj.html ''root درج'']</ref> (e.g. men are a rank above women {{Quran|2|228}}, some messengers are ranked higher than others {{Quran|2|253}}, and people generally {{Quran|6|165}}),<ref>See uses of the word for ranks/degrees applied to people in the Qur'an on the noun section of [https://corpus.quran.com/qurandictionary.jsp?q=drj Qur'an Corpus root ''dāl rā jīm'' (د ر ج) page]</ref> those in the afterlife among the believers similarly have different ranks/degrees.<ref>''darajah | rank'' Sinai, Nicolai. ''Key Terms of the Qur'an: A Critical Dictionary (p.283-289).'' Princeton University Press. Kindle Edition.</ref> Sinai (2023) notes verses such as {{Quran-range|8|2|4}}, {{Quran|20|75}}, {{Quran|4|95–96}}, {{Quran|9|20}} and {{Quran|58|11}} suggest that degrees of belief, action, and knowledge appear to lead to these differences in eschatological rewards''.''<ref>Ibid pp. 288.</ref> This idea is further confirmed in hadith, such as {{Bukhari|||7423|darussalam}} and Qur'anic commentaries.<ref>E.g. commentaries on [https://quranx.com/tafsirs/46.19 Q46:19], [https://quranx.com/tafsirs/8.4 Q8:4], [https://quranx.com/Tafsirs/17.21 Q17:21] or any other verse listed in this section.</ref> No such concept of heavenly ranks exists in the New Testament. There is only the vague statement in [https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=matthew%2016:27&version=NIV Matthew 16:27] (and similar ones in the Pauline epistles and Revelation) that "The Son of Man ... will reward each person according to what they have done."
Sinai notes a parallel that paradise comprises different ranks/orders is found in Ephrem's Hymns of Paradise (e.g. 2:10-13), and the vocabulary he employs in this context includes the Syriac word ''dargā'', a cognate of the Arabic ''darajah'' used in the Qur'an.<ref name=":02">''darajah | rank'' Sinai, Nicolai. ''Key Terms of the Qur'an: A Critical Dictionary (pp. 289)''. Kindle Edition.
Sinai notes a parallel that paradise comprises different ranks/orders is found in Ephrem's Hymns of Paradise (e.g. 2:10-13), and the vocabulary he employs in this context includes the Syriac word ''dargā'', a cognate of the Arabic ''darajah'' used in the Qur'an.<ref name=":02">''darajah | rank'' Sinai, Nicolai. ''Key Terms of the Qur'an: A Critical Dictionary (pp. 289)''. Kindle Edition.
These hymns can be read: [https://ia803106.us.archive.org/4/items/syrarch334903/St.%20Ephrem%20the%20Syrian%20-%20Hymns%20on%20Paradise%20%28Sebastian%20Brock%29.pdf ''SAINT EPHREM HYMNS ON PARADISE''] Introduction and translation by Sebastian Brock. St Vladmimir's Seminary Press, Crestwoof, New York, 1990. E.g. Hymn 2 on pp. 84-89 (p.82-87/239 of the PDF)</ref> And that both the present world and the hereafter are portrayed as hierarchical, with earthly dualities (e.g., day/night, male/female) foreshadowing ultimate salvation or damnation - and that this way of thinking (worldly structures anticipate the stratified reality of the afterlife) parallels other traditions, such as Ephrem’s view of paradise as prefigured in sacred history (e.g., on Noah’s ark).<ref name=":02" />
These hymns can be read: [https://ia803106.us.archive.org/4/items/syrarch334903/St.%20Ephrem%20the%20Syrian%20-%20Hymns%20on%20Paradise%20%28Sebastian%20Brock%29.pdf ''SAINT EPHREM HYMNS ON PARADISE''] Introduction and translation by Sebastian Brock. St Vladmimir's Seminary Press, Crestwoof, New York, 1990. E.g. Hymn 2 on pp. 84-89 (p.82-87/239 of the PDF)</ref> And that both the present world and the hereafter are portrayed as hierarchical, with earthly dualities (e.g., day/night, male/female) foreshadowing ultimate salvation or damnation - and that this way of thinking (worldly structures anticipate the stratified reality of the afterlife) parallels other traditions, such as Ephrem’s view of paradise as prefigured in sacred history (e.g., on Noah’s ark).<ref name=":02" />
Lightyears
Editors, em-bypass-2, Reviewers, rollback, Administrators
3,454

edits

Retrieved from "http://wikiislamica.net/wiki/Special:MobileDiff/139816"